HomeMy WebLinkAbout2003-11-24 - City Commission Workshop Meeting MinutesCITY OF TAMARAC
CITY COMMISSION WORKSHOP MEETING
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 24, 2003
CALL TO ORDER: Mayor Schreiber called the Workshop Meeting of the City
Commission to order on Monday, November 24, 2003, at 9:30 a.m. in Room 105 of
Tamarac City Hall, 7525 NW 88th Avenue, Tamarac, Florida.
PRESENT: Mayor Joe Schreiber, Vice Mayor Karen L. Roberts, Commissioner Edward
C. Partner, Commissioner Beth Flansbaum-Talabisco, and Commissioner Marc L.
Sultanof.
ALSO PRESENT: City Manager Jeffrey L. Miller, City Attorney Mitchell S. Kraft,
Assistant City Manager Michael C. Cernech, and City Clerk Marion Swenson.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE LED BY MAYOR SCHREIBER:
1. NOVEMBER 26, 2003 AGENDA ITEMS:
a. Item No. 6(b). AGREEMENT-7 _ FINANCIAL ADVISORY SERVICES FOR
PROPOSED UTILITIES REVENUE _BOND: (TR10269) Awarding RFP 03-26R,
"Underwriting and Financial Advisory Services", to and executing the Agreement for
Professional Services with Kirkpatrick Pettis Smith & Polian Inc., for Financial Advisory
services, in an amount not to exceed fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000), in conjunction
with the proposed issuance of Utilities Revenue Bonds. Finance Director Dona
Newman said items 1(a) and 1(b) are related regarding the bond financing for
stormwater and utility projects discussed during this year's budget sessions. Finance
Director Newman gave a presentation on the selection process. Mayor Schreiber spoke
about his concern regarding Kirkpatrick Pettis not carrying liability insurance, and
Finance Director Newman said Kirkpatrick Pettis is heavily capitalized and they have a
good reputation. Additionally, they have been in business a long time and are a
national company. Finance Director Newman said she feels certain they will live up to
their obligations. The company has significant assets exceeding the $1 million
insurance that was required. Commissioner Portner questioned reimbursible expenses,
and Finance Director Newman explained these would be out of pocket expenses for the
firm. Commissioner Portner questioned language in the accompanying letter regarding
the Risk Manager's experience, and Risk/Safety Manager Tomaszewski explained she
has no bond experience. Commissioner Portner asked if Risk/Safety Manager
Tomaszewski is part of the finance team associated with the bonds, and Finance
Director Newman said Risk/Safety Manager Tomaszewski is not. Mayor Schreiber
asked if the insurance requirement was included in the RFP. Finance Director Newman
responded the company has over $22 million in assets which would amply cover them
instead of the $1 million insurance policy. Commissioner Sultanof confirmed that the
company said in response to the RFP that they were self -insured.
November 24, 2003
City Commission Workshop
1
b. Item No. 6(c). AGREEMENT — UNDERWRITING SERVICES FOR PROPOSED
UTILITIES REVENUE BOND: (TR10270) Awarding RFP 03-26R, "Underwriting and
Financial Advisory Services", to and executing an agreement with William R. Hough &
Co., for underwriting services, in an amount not to exceed Four Dollars and Fifty -Five
Cents ($4.55) per one thousand dollar ($1,000) bond issued, in conjunction with the
proposed issuance of Utilities Revenue Bonds. This item was included as part of the
discussion with item 1(a) above.
C. Item No. 6(d). DEBT MANAGEMENT POLICY: (TR10284) Adopting a Debt
Management Policy. Finance Director Dona Newman said the City of Tamarac's
finances are stable and our debt position is conservative. Finance Director Newman
gave a presentation and reviewed City's current debt position (citywide, general fund,
and utilities), and citywide debt service (general fund debt service and utilities debt
service). Finance Director Newman said the proposed policy does not suggest changes
in the way we do business; it documents past practices. Finance Director Newman
explained the different types of debt, the method of sale of bonds, and spoke of the
financing team which consists of bond counsel, disclosure counsel, underwriter,
financial advisor and city staff. Finance Director Newman said a debt management
policy is a benefit to the city because adoption of a policy at the commission level
affords us a higher credit rating and lower interest costs. Commissioner Sultanof said in
the past it has been the desire of residents to purchase bonds and asked how the public
is enticed to purchase bonds. Finance Director Newman said the team goes to New
York to get ratings and bids on insurance, not to sell bonds. If the bonds are to be
offered for sale to residents, that needs to be communicated to the underwriters.
Commissioner Sultanof asked if the bonds were advertised and Finance Director
Newman said they were. Jeff Larson, Senior Vice President, Regional Manager,
Kirkpatrick Pettis, said bonds are offered in preliminary statements and on the Internet
one or two weeks before the bonds are placed. They can be advertised in a local
newspaper and be made available for local residents. Bonds have individual maturity
dates and sell in $5,000 denominations. The first priority is to sell bonds and residents
who purchase bonds must accept the interest rate. Kevin Conitz, Senior Vice
President, William R. Hough & Co. said six -seven year bonds will be set aside in the
amount of approximately $250,000 of the largest maturity of bonds for one week or so
after sale. After that, the underwriter has the right to sell bonds. Mayor Schreiber
asked Mr. Conitz' about past experience regarding local participation and Mr. Conitz
responded at least $50,000 up to $300,000 is sold locally. Mr. Conitz said he believes
everyone who wished to purchase bonds last time they were sold had the opportunity to
do so. Advertisements will be placed in the local newspaper and a flyer will be prepared
for the commissioners. Mr. Conitz said there are strict rules that must be followed when
advertising the sale of bonds, but every effort will be made to accommodate the wishes
of the Commission. Commissioner Portner asked if each advisor on the financing team
received a commission, and if all were needed. Finance Director Newman said it is best
to have all four as each has a specialty and this is a highly regulated and technical field.
Commissioner Portner questioned refinancing the 6.2% bonds and Finance Director
Newman said the last time this was reviewed the City was told there was no financial
advantage to refinance; the cost of refinancing would be higher than the recouped
November 24, 2003
City Commission Workshop
2
savings. Additionally, there are rules that regulate the number of times a bond can be
refinanced. Commissioner Portner asked if any cities comparable to Tamarac are debt
free or if the State is debt free. Finance Director Newman replied in the negative.
Commissioner Portner asked what the interest rate of new debt is and Finance Director
Newman said preliminary estimates indicate true interest costs of 4.22%.
Commissioner Portner questioned true interest and Finance Director Newman said it is
the total cost to issue bonds and the interest rate over the life of the bond.
d. Item No. 6(f). GRANT APPLICATION TO BROWARD COUNTY CULTURAL
AFFAIRS DIVISION FOR EDUCATION AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT GRANT:_
(TR10294) Approving the Parks and Recreation Department's grant application to the
Broward County Cultural Affairs Division for an Education and Community Development
Grant in the amount of $14,400.00 with a City match of $14,400.00 to provide an
educational series in public art culminating in a concept for a public art project provided
through a partnership with local professional artists in FY2005 at City of Tamarac
recreation facilities. Parks and Recreation Director Kathleen Margoles gave a
presentation and explained that this is for an education program (three eight -week
courses) for public art for seniors and teens (13-18 years old). The two groups will be
educated on the role of public art, the role of public implementation of public art, and
development of conceptual public art projects. There will be presentations, field trips
and collaboration on a project. Commissioner Sultanof asked if this program will be for
school children and Parks and Recreation Director Margoles said not for the very young
children. Commissioner Sultanof asked if this would fall into the program presented by
the library in their facility in the children's' wing. Parks and Recreation Director
Margoles responded we will be working with the library, using their services for research
components of the project, and this will be a complement to the library's program.
Commissioner Portner asked if the courses would include all arts and Parks and
Recreation Director Margoles said public art could be festivals, music, landscaping, and
culture. Those involved in the program would explore these mediums and then choose
one for the project. Commissioner Portner asked about transportation to the Ft.
Lauderdale museum, and Parks and Recreation Director Margoles said there would not
be trips to the museum; there would be trips to the airport, parks, and other places that
display public art. The trips would be made using our transportation. The City's match
will be staff, our site, and transportation. Commissioner Partner asked if the City had
this program before, and Parks and Recreation Director Margoles said there have been
other grants, but not for this program. We are concentrating on public art because there
are several ongoing projects in the City that require educating the public.
Commissioner Portner asked about necessary materials for the program, and Parks and
Recreation Director Margoles said just art supplies, such as paper, pencils, and pens.
Commissioner Portner questioned Item 6(e) on the consent agenda, in particular what
the development is going to be. VACATION OF EASEMENT — PARCEL "A" OF "ASH
PLAT NO. 1" PLAT: (TR10286) Granting a Vacation of Easement of a fifteen foot (15')
utility easement along the west and south lines of Parcel "A" of the "Ash Plat No. 1" Plat,
according to the Plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 166, Page 50 of the Public
Records of Broward County, Florida (Case No. 16-P-03). Community Development
November 24, 2003
City Commission Workshop
3
Director King said since it is a quasi-judicial item he is prohibited from speaking about
the item, but he could say it is similar to other light industry.
Commissioner Portner questioned Item 6(h) on the consent agenda, in particular staff's
reason for recommending approval. REIMBURSEMENT OF FEES.- ST. MALACHY
CATHOLIC CHURCH: (TR10250) Approving an occupational license flee refund in the
amount of $1,352.25 and building permit fees refund in the amount of $135.00 not to
exceed a total amount of $1,487.25 to be issued to the St. Malachy Catholic Church
located at the northeast corner of NW 615t Street and University Drive for the operation
of the Saint Malachy Annual Carnival conducted on Thursday, October 16, 2003
through Sunday, October 19, 2003 (Case No. 16-MI-03). Community Development
Director King said the funds collected go back to the school; the carnival is a major
fundraiser. This year the church did well in complying with city/state requests for code
requirements. In the past, staff has recommended against reimbursement; this time
staff recommends approval of a waiver of a portion of the building permits and full
refund of the occupational license for the special event. Commissioner Portner asked
what the church made off the event and Community Development Director King said he
did not know. Vice Mayor Roberts asked if they paid the fees up front, and Community
Development Director King said they did.
2. PRESENTATION OF AGENDAS AND BACKUP ON CD ROM: City Clerk
Swenson said much of the credit for this project goes to Lillian Pabon, Records
Coordinator, who worked on creating the CD. City Clerk Swenson gave a presentation
and explained the CD to the commission. Mayor Schreiber asked if the intent was to do
away with the agenda loose leafs, and City Clerk Swenson said eventually that was the
intent. Mayor Schreiber questioned how this would interface with the anticipated
audio/video system, and City Clerk Swenson explained each commissioner would have
a screen at their place on the dais, and there would be a screen for the public to view
also. Vice Mayor Roberts asked if this would be available for use when the Commission
holds meetings off site, and City Clerk Swenson said she would have to check with IT
Director Sucuoglu to see if provisions had been made in the bid for mobility of the
audio/visual equipment.
3. DISCUSSION OF POTENTIAL ACQUISITION OF LAND ADJACENT TO SWIM
CENTRAL SITE: City Manager Miller spoke rcof the possibility of acquiring additional
land next to the five acres donated by Centex; next to the proposed Hampton Hills
project. City Manager Miller said he spoke with the SFWMD and was told it would be
possible to fill in the canal, which would then combine the parcels to increase the total
acreage to 10 acres. City Manager Miller said it is his understanding that funds are
available from the Broward County Land Acquisition program, and he is requesting
authorization from the Commission to move forward and have the realtors, real estate
lawyer and staff begin negotiations with the property owners to see if the City can
acquire the additional acreage. Staff would come back to the Commission before
entering into an agreement. Additionally, City Manager Miller said he would like to
explore the situation to see if the City can get County funding for this acquisition. Vice
Mayor Roberts said she had a concern regarding filling in the canals, especially with
November 24, 2003
City Commission Workshop
4
water flow to Plum Bay and other areas in the vicinity. City Manager Miller said it would
be a small area to fill in; only the stretch along the property managed by Jack Cumming
and the property owned by the Spiritual Warfare Training Institute, plus there would be
an underground culvert. Mayor Schreiber said the end result would be whether the
value of the investment is worth the cost. Commissioner Sultanof said an important
factor is that we have the opportunity to take the land. Commissioner Sultanof said his
concern is for the Aquatic Center and he would not like to see a repetition of the
situation that the City had with The Greens, where they thought the property designated
for a park belonged to their neighborhood, and Commissioner Sultanof asked how the
situation could be averted. City Manager Miller said it would be the commission's call.
When the site plan is approved the Commission can designate access to the park off
581h Street. Commissioner Sultanof asked if enough landscaping would be placed
around the park to make sure Hampton Hills had no claim of access off their property.
Commissioner Sultanof asked if the SFWD would pay for the conduit and City Manager
Miller said it could be explored. Mayor Schreiber said a public park is accessible to
everyone in the public. Community Development Director King said a buffer will
separate the park from the Hampton Hills development. Mayor Schreiber asked for an
expression of interest for the City Manager to begin the process of negotiating for the
acquisition of the property and everyone was in favor.
4. DISCUSSION REGARDING A CHARTER SCHOOL FOR TAMARAC:
Commissioner Portner said Tamarac is in need of a high school and a proposal is being
made by the School Board for a high school in Sunrise and one in North Lauderdale.
Commissioner Portner said the Cinnamon Plaza Building is almost entirely vacated and
asked if City Manager Miller would look into it to see if the building could be used as a
Charter School location. City Attorney Kraft said there are two issues here; whether the
City holds the Charter or whether a private company comes in and opens a Charter
School. Commissioner Partner suggested the City purchase the building and a private
company run the school. Mayor Schreiber said he believed that facility is too small for a
high school. Mayor Schreiber said Pembroke Pines had a lot of success putting in
Charter Schools using a private company. Perhaps we could attract them to come
forward and make a presentation on what Tamarac could do. Commissioner Portner
said he would like to investigate the possibilities. Mayor Schreiber asked for an
expression of interest and all agreed to look into the possibilities. City Manager Miller
said it is his understanding that the commission wants to explore the idea of a Charter
School in general and have alternatives placed before them; staff will come back to the
commission with alternatives.
5. DISCUSSION REGARDING ESTABLISHING A RESIDENTIAL COLOR
PALETTE: Commissioner Partner said he received an e-mail regarding a house at
6008 NW 70 Avenue that had been painted purple. Lauderhill is taking up the matter of
house colors, and before it gets out of hand in Tamarac, Commissioner Portner said he
would like an expression of interest for a color palette. Mayor Schreiber said this is a
serious matter; how much control does the commission want to have over the people in
the City. Mayor Schreiber questioned whether the commission has the right to do that;
there are good points and bad regarding this issue. Mayor Schreiber suggested
November 24, 2003
City Commission Workshop
5
exploring the matter. Commissioner Portner said in his community there is a two-story
home that is painted purple while the rest of the neighborhood's homes are painted in
earth tones. There should be latitude, but it should not repress the value of the homes.
Commissioner Sultanof said in many communities the organizations/associations have
a very close call on what people can paint. For example in Westwood 21 the
association asked the people to reconsider their color choice and after deliberation, the
homeowner acceded. Commissioner Sultanof said the association should be the first
stop to keep the neighborhoods in good order. Commissioner Portner said what if there
is no association? Mayor Schreiber said if there is no association or no deed
restrictions, then it falls upon the City and we need to look at it from both sides. Vice
Mayor Roberts said there are differences in shades of various colors. Commissioner
Sultanof asked when people purchase a home in Tamarac and come forward for
permits, if the house is not painted or the roof needs maintenance, how does that fall
into place? Building Official Jones said the code requires owners of property to
maintain the exterior of the property in a clean condition. It does not regulate color.
Mayor Schreiber asked for an expression of interest to look into a color palette.
Commissioners Portner and Talabisco and Mayor Schreiber said yes to exploring code
amendments. Vice Mayor Roberts and Commissioner Sultanof were not in favor.
There being no further business to come before the City Commission, Mayor Schreiber
adjourned the workshop meeting at 11:00 a.m.
Marion Swenson, CMC
City Clerk
November 24, 2003
City Commission Workshop
6